Metal Roofing Cost VS Shingles: Which One Makes More Sense In 2025?
Today’s topic: Metal roofing cost vs shingles – which one makes more sense in 2025?
How about replacing your roof? That big question always shows up right away: Do I spend the extra on metal, or just go with shingles like everyone else? It’s not only about looks – it’s cost, how long the thing will last, and whether it’s worth it for your house.
And here’s the kicker: the sticker price isn’t the whole story. There’s more to it.
Breaking Down Shingle Roofing Costs:
Shingles are basically the “default” roof in the U.S. Drive through almost any neighborhood—you’ll see them everywhere.
Initial Cost Of Shingles:
Shingles are the cheaper option upfront. Typically, you can expect to pay between $3.50 and $5.50 per square foot for installation. For a regular-sized house, that’s somewhere in the $8,000–$12,000 ballpark. Not small change, but it doesn’t sting as bad as metal.
Factors Affecting Shingle Costs:
The price tag increases if you opt for the premium options, such as architectural shingles. Labor is another piece—ripping off old shingles takes time and money. Still, no matter how you slice it, shingles are almost always cheaper than metal.
Breaking Down Metal Roofing Costs:
Metal roofs have gained popularity in recent years. Folks like the idea of something tough that won’t need replacing again anytime soon.
Initial Cost of Metal Roofing:
Here’s where the eyes widen: metal roofs (standing seam) usually cost $8–$14 per square foot installed. That means $18,000 to $30,000 for a typical house. Quite a leap compared to shingles.
Why Metal Costs More Upfront?
It’s not just about pricey panels. Installing metal is a more technical job. Crews need training, and not every roofer has it. Add that to the manufacturing process, and you’ve got your higher cost.
Metal Roofing Cost VS Shingles: Which One Makes More Sense?
Metal roofs generally come with higher upfront expenses but offer a much longer lifespan, typically between 40 to 70 years.
In comparison, asphalt shingles have a lifespan of 12 to 20 years. So, while the initial cost of metal roofing appears to be significantly more expensive than that of shingles, the energy savings and long-term durability make the investment worthwhile.
Additionally, you can consult with top-tier roofing companies, such as the Cleveland roofing company, if you are located in the United States, for an effective solution to your roofing woes.
Additionally, while conducting this comparison, I took into consideration five major parameters. So, without wasting time, let’s check out which ones make more sense for you:
1. Longevity: Cost Over Time
Upfront costs tell one story. Long-term costs? Totally different.
Shingle Lifespan: Most asphalt shingles last around 15–25 years. Climate plays a big role—heat, heavy storms, ice—all can shorten that number. Which means a lot of homeowners end up replacing shingles twice (sometimes three times) in their lives.
Metal Lifespan: Metal is built for the long haul: 40–70 years is common. Some copper and zinc roofs last over a century. Spread that out over decades, and suddenly, metal doesn’t seem so expensive anymore.
2. Energy Efficiency And Savings:
Your roof doesn’t just keep you dry. It also plays with your power bill.
Shingle Energy Efficiency: Standard shingles soak up heat. Which, in summer, means higher AC bills. Some new “cool roof” shingles are better, but they still can’t beat metal.
Metal Roofing Efficiency: Metal reflects sunlight. Period. That can cut cooling costs by 20–30% in the summer. Over the decades, those savings start to balance out the upfront hit to your wallet.
3. Maintenance And Repairs:
Every roof needs love at some point. The real question is how much.
Shingle Maintenance: Shingles wear out in obvious ways—curling, cracking, or losing granules. Strong winds can rip them loose. Repairs are usually cheap, but you’ll deal with them more often.
Metal Maintenance: Metal roofs? Much lower maintenance. They don’t rot, pests leave them alone, and mildew isn’t an issue. Every now and then, a panel or fastener may need attention, but compared to shingles, it’s practically hands-off.
4. Aesthetic And Value Considerations:
Looks and resale value matter too, even if we don’t always admit it.
Shingle Appearance: Shingles provide a classic look. They’re versatile, tons of colors and styles, and they blend into just about any house design.
Metal Appearance: Metal roofs lean towards a modern aesthetic. Some people love the clean lines, others… not so much. The good news is that modern metal roofs can mimic the appearance of shingles, slate, or even tile. So if you’re picturing a farm shed, don’t.
5. Resale Value Impact:
This one’s sneaky. The roof choice can significantly impact what buyers think.
Shingle Value: Since shingles are the norm, they don’t add much to resale. An older shingle roof might even scare buyers—“Oh great, another expense.”
Metal Value: Metal roofs usually add value. Buyers see low maintenance, long life, and peace of mind. Stats show you can recover 60–70% of the cost when you sell.
Metal Roofing Cost Vs Shingles: Cost Recap
Quick rundown:
- Shingles→ cheaper upfront, shorter lifespan, more fixes.
- Metal→ costs more at the start, but lasts decades, has fewer problems, and helps with energy bills.
So, the real question: save money now, or save it later?
Metal Roofing Cost Vs Shingles: Which One Is More Affordable?
There’s no “one right answer.”
If money’s tight or you plan to move in a few years, shingles make sense.
If you’re staying put and think long-term, metal pays off.
At the end of the day, it’s not just about the cost per square foot—it’s about what fits your home, your budget, and your plans. And hey, talk to a good local roofer. They know how each option holds up in your climate, which sometimes matters more than the numbers.
Read Also:
